A Talent for Murder review
By Joel Humphries · Watched 10.22.26
★★★ 3 / 5
Full review · May contain spoilers
I wanted A Talent for Murder to be more fun than it was. Helen Mirren plays Patricia Highsmith, the author of the Tom Ripley novels, as an unpleasant recluse who knows a great deal about murder and enjoys making her visitor uncomfortable. Alden Ehrenreich plays the American literary agent sent to Switzerland to persuade her to write another Ripley book. He wants a contract. She wants to fuck with him. That should have been a pretty entertaining arrangement.
Mirren does a good job, as she always does. Highsmith isn't supposed to be likable, but I wanted her games to have more charm or wit. She has knives, guns, and poisons, and a considerable interest in how somebody might use them. There's plenty of material for a nasty little back-and-forth between these two people, neither of whom is necessarily operating from the purest motives. The film just never made that exchange as smart or interesting as I wanted it to be.
Ehrenreich goes all in. He embodies this ambitious, morally questionable guy trying to get something out of a woman who isn't inclined to cooperate. He was once positioned as a potential major Hollywood star, and that never quite developed the way people seemed to expect. But he's a good actor, and I thought he did solid work with what he was given here.
The early exchanges promise more than the movie ultimately delivers. I kept waiting for it to get sharper, funnier, or more compelling, and it never quite got there. I liked it enough for one viewing, but nothing about it made me want to go back.
This is solid, but it feels like a Sunday-afternoon streaming movie to me. The performances are worth watching, and it's good enough to pass the time. I just didn't find it impressive enough to make a particular effort to see it in a theater.